3-D Nail Art Judging Criteria 2017

Judge 1

Originality - 5 Points

  • the design is innovative (new and original)
  • the design is unique (different from other designs we have seen in the past and from other entries)
  • the design is within the guidelines of the copyright rules

Visual Interest - 10 Points

  • the design captures your attention
  • the design holds your attention
  • the design continues to draw your attention to new details

Color - 10 Points

  • the colors enhance the design
  • the colors complement each other

Presentation - 5 Points

  • this entry is presented within the 3-D rules
  • this entry is presented as if it is a special piece of art
  • care was taken to make this presentation neat and clean
  • written statement is included and is complete and understandable

Judge 2

Balance - 5 Points

  • various elements of the design are well-balanced, neither too sparse or too busy
  • the sum of the design is in harmony with the parts of the whole design

Design and Detail - 10 Points

  • the design enhances the theme
  • the design is well thought out
  • the detail of design is clean and precise
  • the design has adequate detail

Dimension - 10 Points

  • the artwork is obvious and within the guidelines 3-D rules
  • the dimension enhances the theme and is balanced
  • the design may not protrude more than 1" in height from the tip surface

Overall Impression - 10 Points

  • this design makes an excellent overall impression
  • this design is complete and needs no improvement

Judge 3

Complexity - 10 Points

  • the design is challenging, demanding skill and effort
  • the design involves multiple techniques

Workmanship - 10 Points

  • the overall quality of the work demonstrates outstanding artistic skills
  • the workmanship is neat, clean and precise

**Tip Length - 5 Points

  • the tips are graduated in length and size
  • the length of tips must be no linger than 2"
  • the width may be no wider than 3/4" if they were flattened out

Theme - 10 Points

  • the theme is obvious and completely developed
  • the theme is continued on all 10 nails
  • the design enhances the theme

Property of Nailpro Competition @2017 Creative Age Publications. All rules including judging criteria are NOT ALLOWED TO BE USED UNLESS WRITTEN APPROVAL IS GIVEN FROM NAILPRO COMPETITION DIRECTOR ONLY!  All Nailpro Competition rules are copywritten and All rights reserved.


 

 

Scoring Guide 2 Hands

Scoring Guide 1 Hand
10 = Flawless 5 = Average 5 = Flawless
9 = Almost  Flawless 4 = Below Average 4 = Very Good
8 = Very Good 3 = Poor 3 = Average
= Good 2 = Very Poor 2 = Below Average
6 = Above Average 1 = Unacceptable 1 = Very Poor